Tuesday, October 14, 2025

2025 NLCS Game 2 Thread: Oct 14 @ Brewers, 5p

Yoshinobu Yamamoto vs. Freddy Peralta.

Let's take the Brewers' NLCS Game 1 pitching lineup as an anomaly. The good news is, we've now gotten a good look at six of Milwaukee's relievers, especially Quinn Priester, who pitched innings two through five. And we did get some hits and walks off them (7 H and 8 BB, respectfully), against only 4 Ks, showing better plate discipline than we had against the Phillies in the NLCS.

But today's Game 2 features an actual starting pitcher for the Brewers, Freddy Peralta, and he's a pretty good one at that. Peralta's 5.5 WAR and 2.70 ERA this year ranked him seventh in the majors. Peralta also shut us down in the first of two starts against the Dodgers this year (July 7: 6.0 IP, 5 H, 0 ER, 1 BB and 7 Ks), and he earned the win (but was less effective) in his second start against us (July 19: 5.0 IP, 5 H, 4 ER, 3 BB and 4 Ks). Perhaps that bodes well for the Dodgers, as he's at least trending in a favorable direction.

(Peralta also started twice in the 2025 NLDS against the Cubs: winning NLDS G1 (5.2 IP, 4 H, 2 ER, 3 BB and 9 Ks), but losing NLDS G4 (4.0 IP, 3 H, 3 ER, 2 BB and 6 Ks). Again, trending in a favorable direction.)

But let's not get distracted from some glaring issues with our own lineup. Shohei Ohtani, 0-for-2 (albeit with 3 BBs) yesterday, is now batting .138 in the leadoff spot. Mookie Betts was 0-for-4 and Teoscar Hernadez 0-for-3 yesterday.

Without those three hitting, we barely eked out the two runs we needed to win Game 1--but let's remember, we've scored two runs or fewer against the Brewers in five of seven games this season, and last night's game was the only time we came out with a win.

And Andy Pages, 0-for-3 yesterday, is now batting .037 in the postseason. I mean, I don't hope for Michael Conforto (who thankfully is not on the NLCS roster). But even he can hit better than .037.

Not to mention, Teoscar fricking' TOOTBLANned yesterday, as well.

If the best highlight the Brewers get from the 2025 NLCS is this absurd double play, I'd be thrilled. Unfortunately, I think they'll have many more highlights in this series. Hopefully, just not any Brewers highlights tonight.

74 comments:

spank said...

I'm just hoping for the best today

QuadSevens said...

Game 2

Ohtani DH
Betts SS
Freeman 1B
Smith C
Muncy 3B
Hernandez, T RF
Edman 2B
Hernandez, K LF
Pages CF

Yamamoto P

QuadSevens said...

I’m going to be greedy. I want at least 4 hits with RISP.

spank said...

thanks Quad

QuadSevens said...

No problem spank!

Steve Sax said...

Thanks for the lineup, Quad!

I wore my Ohtani shirt, but clearly it's not working. He Ks.

Mookie walks.

Steve Sax said...

Freeman flies to right. Two out. Here's Will Smith.

Steve Sax said...

Smith Ks. 19 pitches for Peralta in the first, but we again look awful in the first inning (just like every playoff game except NLWC G1) .

Steve Sax said...

First pitch by Yamamoto is a HR by Chourio. What the fuck.

QuadSevens said...

First pitch? Ugh.

spank said...

aw shit

Steve Sax said...

Turang grounds out. One out.

karen said...

@SPANKY......Remember what I said about Yoshi and the first inning???? BOOOOO!!

QuadSevens said...

Alright. It’s only one run. Let’s get it back now!

spank said...

@karen.....yep. just like you said

Steve Sax said...

3-0 count from Peralta to Teo. Do something good, Teoscar!

Steve Sax said...

Teoscar HR!!!

Steve Sax said...

LET'S GOOOOOOOO

QuadSevens said...

TEO!!!

spank said...

TEO!!!

karen said...

PAGES!!!

Steve Sax said...

PAGES! An unlikely double from Pages scores Kiké and puts us up 2-1!

WOW

spank said...

Pages comes through!!

Steve Sax said...

Pages lifts his average to .071!

Steve Sax said...

Shohei retired, but at least he made contact this time.

2-1 LA, mid-2.

Steve Sax said...

Peralta is now at 45 pitches through two innings.

Steve Sax said...

Dammit Muncy, horrible.

Steve Sax said...

Frelick forces Vaughn at second. One out.

Steve Sax said...

Yoshi gets a K on Caleb Durbin for the second out!

Steve Sax said...

Bauers grounds to Mookie.

2-1 LA through 2.

Steve Sax said...

Mookie swings at the first pitch and grounds to short. Come on, Mookie. Peralta is on the ropes, what are you doing? Take a damn pitch!

Steve Sax said...

Freeman grounds to short as well.

spank said...

limped through the top of the third. smh

Steve Sax said...

Yamamoto gets his second K of the game on Chourio, who took him yard on the game's first pitch.

Steve Sax said...

Contreras line out to Mookie to end the third.

Yamamoto with 33 pitches so far; Peralta with 54 pitches.

Let's keep working Peralta's pitch count, guys!

karen said...

Poor Max!

spank said...

at least the bats are making contact

Steve Sax said...

Two-out ground rule double or Tommy Tanks!

spank said...

woop

Steve Sax said...

Kiké Ks.

Peralta with 71 pitches through four, but has held the Dodgers to only two runs (and four hits).

Steve Sax said...

Yelich Ks on four straight splitters by Yamamoto! One out.

Steve Sax said...

Durbin Ks for the third out!

Four Ks for Yamamoto. 47 pitches through four.

2-1 LA

spank said...

Yosh!

Steve Sax said...

Peralta plunks Pages. That's bullshit.

Steve Sax said...

Make them pay, Shohei

Steve Sax said...

Ohtani Ks AGAIN

Steve Sax said...

Ohtani swung at a ball way out of the zone. Disaster.

spank said...

damn shohei. wtf

Steve Sax said...

Come on, Mookie!

Steve Sax said...

Shohei is 4-for-34 this postseason, with two hits coming in NLWC G1. Wow.

Steve Sax said...

Dammit Mookie, GIDP? Come on, dude.

Steve Sax said...

That's Betts' second GIDP in two nights.

spank said...

meh

Steve Sax said...

Now we’ve got Freeman swinging at the first pitch. He flies out.

spank said...

first pitch swinging. i just don't get it

Steve Sax said...

Yamamoto gutted through the fifth there, btw.

Steve Sax said...

Muncy! Let’s GO

Steve Sax said...

Great AB there by Max. Take notes, Dodgers

QuadSevens said...

MUNCY!!!!

spank said...

Maxy!!!

Steve Sax said...

Peralta chased. Uribe replaces.

Let’s GOOOOOOOOO

spank said...

good inning there. one more for yoshi me thinks

spank said...

kiki double. go for the kill!!

spank said...

shohei comes through. wow

spank said...

5-1 LA

spank said...

bases juiced for shohei

spank said...

shohei Ks.

spank said...

BOOOOOO

spank said...

missed opportunity with bases loaded again. smh

spank said...

yoshi going for complete game

spank said...

Yoshi!!!!!!

spank said...

that's a wrap

Steve Sax said...

WIN

Steve Sax said...

Sorry, missed the seventh inning onward because of dinner.

PGT up.